Green energy and Ontario’s surging cost of power

(August 29, 2014) Hydro bills have increased dramatically since the provincial government introduced its Green Energy Act.

Ontario’s electricity prices have been soaring ever since the province’s 2009 introduction of its Green Energy Act, resulting in a long-term decline in demand across the province.

The cost of power in the province, according to the Ontario Energy Board’s yearbook for distributors, has increased from $8.9 billion in 2009 to $12.42 billion in 2013, marking a near 40% increase and far higher than the 1.85% annual average inflation over that time. Prior to 2009, the cost of power had actually fallen from $9.7 billion in 2005 to just over $9 billion in 2008, at the onset of the financial crisis.

Yet demand over the last decade has fallen dramatically – having dropped from 157 terawatt hours (TWh) in 2005 to 141 in 2013, or about 11 percent. Demand dropped dramatically through the 2008-09 financial crisis and has yet to return to its pre-crisis level. The chart below highlights the divergence in the price of energy compared to demand.

soaring bill

Worse still for Ontario’s ratepayers is that those cost increases are expected to continue over the next 3 years, with Energy Minister Bob Chiarelli recently warning ratepayers that their bills will increase by 50% over that time.

The biggest reason for the increase is renewable energy (wind, solar and biogas), which now accounts for about 6% of all supply, but is expected to more than double in the coming years. The cost of generation from those new sources is significantly more than traditional forms of generation (hydro, nuclear and coal).

According to the Ontario Power Authority, one megawatt hour (MWh) of energy from nuclear and hydro costs $59 and $43, respectively, while that same amount of energy from solar and wind costs $504 and $108 respectively. As those new renewable generators connect to the grid, those costs will be passed on to ratepayers.

The effects of these expensive forms of energy and the resulting price increases are already being felt in the province, with the chief executive officer of Magna – the global auto parts maker that was founded in Ontario – recently telling its shareholders that he was “worried” about high electricity prices in the province and said the company had no intention to open any new plants in Ontario. The province has lost 119,000 manufacturing jobs since the end of 2008 and 287,000 jobs since 2005, according to Statistics Canada.

Brady Yauch is an economist and Executive Director of the Consumer Policy Institute, a sister organization of Energy Probe. Email:

This entry was posted in Reforming Ontario's Electrical Generation Sector, Reforming Ontario's Local Electrical Distribution Sector, Renewables, Utility Reform and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Green energy and Ontario’s surging cost of power

  1. markwbell says:

    Mr Yauch: What a confusing piece. Renewables are a drop in the bucket, yet they are responsible for massive historical cost increases. It ain’t so! You and Tom really need to get your act together and pin the tail on the real donkeys- bloated LDCs, nuclear overruns, political miscalculations, and all other, larger, price gougers.

    • energy01 says:

      INot sure what you find confusing, Mark as this is not new information and easily verifiable if you care to take the time to actually research the topic. Considering your involvement in the renewable energy industry, I am surprised that you would not put forth a more technically-proficient argument.

    • consumerpolicyinstitute says:

      Hi Mark. EP has a long history of criticizing nuclear cost overruns and “bloated LDCs”, as you put it, not to mention political interference in the energy sector. We don’t think renewables should be free from those same criticisms. The historical cost increases are a result of many factors, but since the introduction of the Green Energy act, the impact of renewables on price increases has risen dramatically and will continue to do so in the future.

      We are not opposed to renewable energy. We, in fact, think it will have a role to play in a diverse, vibrant electricity sector. We are opposed to supporting renewables at all cost.


  2. markwbell says:

    remaining confused. let me understand your logic by way of example – co2 has increased and global temperatures have increased, therefore the temperature increase was caused by co2 increase. With this logic, the GEA came into being in 2009, price increased took off in 2009, therefore they are the fault of the GEA.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s